Since her 2015 debut album HAIZ, Hailee Steinfeld has only released some singles and collaborations. While her singles like “Starving” and “Most Girls” proved successful, it’s about time we got an EP to listen to from her.
Her acting role as Emily Junk in Pitch Perfect 2 and Pitch Perfect 3 along with her lead roles in Bumblebee and Edge of Seventeen took her away from music for a while and momentarily closed that door. Now, she’s begun to reopen this closed door in her music by releasing Half Written Story in May. It is the first of two EPs to be released this year. Consisting of five heartfelt songs, the EP takes listeners through Steinfeld’s thoughts and emotions after her public relationship splits.
Beginning with “I Love You’s,” Steinfeld sets the tone for the EP. She brings her usual pop sound and beat with sad and heavy lyrics. With an intriguing hook coming at the beginning, she pulls you in immediately. The song makes it clear that she is not okay through the lyrics “no more I love you’s / until I’m okay.” She also makes the song feel relatable by saying it’s too easy to say I love you because many listeners have probably regretted or questioned their use of it before. The most memorable lyrics are “I blamed it on the time zones/ I blamed it on my eyes closed/ I blamed it on the world like it owes me.” The direct meaning is a little ambiguous, but she makes self-blame a theme of this EP.
See the official video below.
“Your Name Hurts” followed with a sound similar to much of Julia Michaels’s music. It has that background sound and faint pop beat, creating a song that many would slow dance to. It feels even more personal than “I Love You’s” because of the blatant connection to a past relationship that filled her with happiness, but left her with sadness and without a part of herself when it fell apart. Considering it plays on the EP title Half Written Story with the lyrics “We’re a half-written story without any ending / You left me to figure it out / Filled me with ecstasy, left with the best of me / But where’s the rest of me now,” I believe it should have been the opener. As what I think is the most powerful song on the album, I think she needed to make more of a statement with it.
The third song “End This (L.O.V.E.)” is a take on the romantic classic “L-o-v-e (L Is For The Way You Look At Me)” by The Hit Crew. Obviously, Steinfeld’s version is not as sweet and tender as the original. It is actually quite the opposite. The song shines light on an ex as a vindictive liar with the chorus “L is for the way you lied to me / O is I’m the only one who sees that / V, you’re so vindictive, so I’ll be vicious / And E-N-D this L-O-V-E, love, love.” Steinfeld flips the tone to gratefulness through the lyrics “No one’s ever messed me up like you did / Thanks to you, babe, now I know what love is.” She’s recognizing that the pain she went through taught her what love is.
“Man Up” is a different vibe than the rest of the EP and almost feels like it doesn’t belong. Even though it maintains the theme of the rest of the songs, the actual sound is a little off, most likely because of the rap. While I respect her expanding her genre and trying something new and creative, I don’t believe it fits well with the story she is telling. While the other songs do reference the other person’s faults in her relationships, they focused more on her emotions after, whereas this song really isn’t about her. I do like the song, but I wish it had been a single instead of being a direct part of this “half written story.”
The last song on the EP was released back on New Year’s Day as a single with a music video following. “Wrong Direction” was the first glimpse into her emotions and into one specific public breakup that broke more than just her heart. It also hinted at what her newest music would feel like, represent, and sound like. She ends the album with a powerful song about not seeing the red flags. Opening with “I don’t hate you / No, I couldn’t if I wanted to / I just hate all the hurt that you put me through / And that I blame myself for letting you,” she shares that she blames herself for letting her ex hurt her in their relationship and not seeing the issues sooner. By making it the last song on the EP, she ends it all with reflection, leaving the next step ambiguous and listeners with a cliff-hanger about what’s to come.
See the music video below.
Overall, the EP is cohesive give or take “Man Up.” Filled with strong and deep lyrics and flowing melodies, it is a beautiful story of her heartbreak. Half Written Story made me feel every emotion with Steinfeld and I can’t wait to eventually hear the ending.
Listen to Half Written Story below.
Rating: 8/10
Let us know your thoughts on Half Written Storyin the comments or on Twitter!
Stream Half Written Story on Spotifyand Apple Music.
Follow Hailee Steinfeld on Twitter,Facebook,Instagram,and YouTube.
Follow Beyond the Stage to stay up-to-date on all of your favorite artists.
- 2023 iHeartRadio Jingle Ball Tour Lineups Ranked - September 29, 2023
- Staff Picks: Song of the Summer - June 21, 2023
- New Music Friday: September 16, 2022 - September 16, 2022
